Hawks All Americans
| Richard Geiger | Soccer | 1960 |
| Joseph Kydon | Soccer | 1961 |
| Neil Robinson | Wrestling | 1961 |
| Carl Svenson | Wrestling | 1961 |
| Cliff Ward | Wrestling | 1961 |
| Andy Hoffman | Soccer | 1962 |
| Neil Robinson | Wrestling | 1962 |
| Jon Pond | Soccer | 1963 |
| Robert Hurlebaus | Soccer | 1965 |
| Robert Hurlebaus | Baseball | 1965 |
| Mike Landau | Soccer | 1966 |
| James Babcock | Basketball | 1966 |
| Magne Engenes | Soccer | 1968 |
| Richard Lupi | Soccer | 1969 |
| Joseph Friedman | Soccer | 1969 |
| William Sweet | Wrestling | 1973 |
| Steve Dopkin | Golf | 1973 |
| Emerson Jean-Louis | Soccer | 1967 |
| William Seymour | Baseball | 1983 |
| Elvis Miller | Soccer | 1985 |
| Hanson Samimi | Soccer | 1987 |
| John Kolesar | Lacrosse | 1989 |
| Dan Munoz | Baseball | 1989 |
| Ken Munoz | Baseball | 1989 |
| Vaughn Christopher | Soccer | 1989 |
| Jack Watson II | Golf | 1989 |
| Steve Torsoe | Golf | 1990 |
| Abdiel Marin | Basketball | 1990 |
| Delano Chandler | Basketball | 1991 |
| Susan Williams | Basketball | 1992 |
| Tim Casey | Baseball | 1992 |
| Bobby Everett | Golf | 1992 |
| Keith Finnerty | Basebal | 1993 |
| Webert Innocent | Soccer | 1993 |
| Peter Fortune | Baseball | 1995 |
| Kevin Reilly | Golf | 1995 |
| Dayne John | Soccer | 1995 |
| Greg Donohue | Baseball | 1996 |
| Cassandra Dabbs | Basketball | 1998 |
| Jamie Rosario | Volleyball | 1998 |
| Cassandra Dabbs | Basketball | 1999 |
| Andrew Guinan | Baseball | 1999 |
| Alyrio Howard | Soccer | 2000 |
| Oketto Chambers | Soccer | 2001 |
| Justin Michalek | Baseball | 2003 |
| Jo Rene Valentin | Soccer | 2005 |
| Steven Diaz | Soccer | 2005 |
| Luis Rosario | Baseball | 2006 |
| Amrit Etwaroo | Golf | 2009 |
| Ryan Spicer | Baseball | 2009 |
| John Ziznewski | Baseball | 2011 |
| Colby Lewis | Golf | 2012 |
| Tommie Starkes | Basketball | 2013 |
| Erika Richards | Basketball | 2014 |
| Elina Arakelyan | Tennis | 2015 |
| Lysander Payano | Tennis | 2016 |
| Jose Robles Lopez | Tennis | 2017 |
| John Daly | Baseball | 2019 |
| Sean McGarvey | Golf | 2019 |
| Brianna Almonte | Volleyball |
2021 |
| Tayejon Lynch | Basketball |
2024 |
| Ryan Foody | Baseball |
2025 |